When tested with an XRF instrument almost all of the KitchenAid brand mixer attachments (of the many that I have tested to date) have been positive for Lead*.
This is true of the ones with the white coating and of the ones with the shiny or dull gray finish. This also includes the top-knobs on the whisk attachment [particularly odd – considering the main body of said whisk is made of intrinsically Lead-free stainless steel!).
In general, over the years since I originally posted this information, KitchenAid has been completely dismissive of this concern in their communications with my readers (who often contact them after reading the posts I have written on this subject.)
While I am not as concerned about the white enameled paddles and blades (if used occasionally), I am DEFINITELY concerned about the shiny or dull gray “Burnished” bare metal paddles and blades — as I have heard from countless readers that (after even one use) those paddles tend to leave gray streaks in the food as it is mixed. [Note: when these “Burnished” attachments are purchased new, they have a shiny finish, but after use they start turning a dull gray.]
December 2018 Update: Good News — just recently [in 2018], I learned that KitchenAid has FINALLY come out with a version of their blades and paddles in full stainless steel construction!!! I have not yet tested these (and would like to do so – to confirm that the top knob is not still made from grey, leaded “pot metal“), but I am excited to get my hands on these new products and test them! [And I can’t help but think that it has been the influence of you, my readers that put consumer demand on KitchenAid to make these Lead-free versions of their paddles and mixing attachments.]
From the William Sonoma website:
From the Williams Sonoma website (click image to link through.)
Note (perhaps of interest): By selling the stainless set as an intentional “upgrade” it has to make you wonder what their official stance is on the non-upgraded original attachments!
To see more KitchenAid attachments and other KitchenAid branded products I have tested (many of which test positive for Lead when tested with an XRF instrument), Click HERE.
Related: #AskTamara: What do you use to test for Lead?
For the image above:
KitchenAid Attachments, c. 2014: As high as 2,434 ppm Lead
Left to right (in the image above and below):
1) KitchenAid: 1,655 ppm LEAD on white,
2) KitchenAid: 110 ppm LEAD in top knob,
3) KitchenAid: 2,434 ppm LEAD,
4) KitchenAid: 333 ppm LEAD,
&
5) last one, NOT KitchenAid Brand, and… NO Lead! [Amazon link here to this product*].
The 4th one from the left (I was told) is newish purchased [c. 2014]. I don’t know the exact ages of the other ones.
For Lead-free options click this link!
For all of my Lead-free home #SaferChoices, click here!
The readings are XRF readings done by me [and yes, I am trained and certified in using an XRF] and they are generally considered “surface” readings. It is hard to know how deep/thick the item’s surface coating is — and that would inform us as to whether the Lead-reading is all in the coating or if it is reading through the coating to a higher Lead level in the substrate (metal base) underneath. The three white items are all [some kind of] enamel-coated metal.
As you can (and many manufacturers do) make kitchen items and cookware with no Lead – we (as consumers) should expect high standards from a name like KitchenAid, so I personally am disappointed to find any Lead in these products — regardless of whether or not it is leaching.
Thank you for reading and for sharing my posts (your sharing of my posts helps me to generate advertising income that helps to pay for the independent consumer goods testing work I do!)
As always, please let me know if you have any questions.
Tamara Rubin
#LeadSafeMama
*Amazon links are affiliate links. If you purchase something after clicking on one of my links I may receive a small percentage of what you spend at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my work in this way.
Carrie says
April 30, 2017 at 1:16 pmSo the lead is only in the top part of the whisk, not in the part that has contact with food? Have you found any lead free whisk attachments?
Thank you for your work!
Sabrina says
November 18, 2017 at 10:14 pmHow is that even LEGAL?! These are food-contact items?! AAARRRGGHHH!!!!
Jessica says
December 7, 2018 at 10:54 amWow! Thanks for your research and post. I don’t have a KitchenAid. Have you tested a Bosch mixer?
frank says
December 8, 2018 at 6:10 pmThe gray film on bare aluminum parts is aluminum oxide (nontoxic). Kitchen aid warns of this and gives instruction on preventing it! Lead in stainless would be an added expense with no benefits. It would cost more for an inferior product.
Tamara says
December 9, 2018 at 10:19 amThe thing is they are not just aluminum. I would classify them as pot-metal since they are testing positive for Lead with XRF technology.
T says
December 18, 2018 at 2:30 amHi Tamara, Thank you so much for informing us about this. I’m afraid to use my kitchenaid mixer now but I’m hoping your answer to the following question will alleviate my worries. When your XRF technology detects lead in the white coated beater, is it definitely detecting the lead in that white surface coating or is it possible it’s detecting the lead that is in the metal, underneath the white coating? If it’s the latter then maybe the white coating protects our food from the lead in the metal underneath? I’m really hoping you can answer this question. I looked up the stainless steel beaters that you mentioned are now available but the description says they’re for 4.5 and 5 qrt. bowls and someone who tried them said they were way too small to use in the 5 qrt bowls to work properly. Thanks again for all the work you do for us.
Tamara says
December 18, 2018 at 1:31 pmHi T!
I really can’t say (based on the type of testing that I do) whether or not the white attachments are likely to be leaching / if the Lead is in the surface coating or just the substrate underneath. I just know that I have found Lead in both types of attachments.
To find out if there is lead in the white coating (and to confirm it is not just detecting the lead in the metal underneath the white coating) the white coating would have to be scraped off and tested separately. This is called destructive testing and I don’t do destructive testing with the work I do.
Sorry to not have a better answer for you. If you subscribe to my blog here you will get updates with new posts and if I ever post an answer to this question you will be among the first to know! 🙂
Tamara
Charlene says
April 8, 2019 at 3:08 pmThe coating is made of polyester, and the underneath is the same as the metal attachments (aluminum) so it’s possible your reading is the bottom of it. Also, they only leave gray streaks if they’ve been washed wrong. I had that happen when my husband washed them in the dishwasher 🙁 they turned a dull gray and then turned everything it touched gray too. We read the manual afterwards and it does say they are not dishwasher safe. I thought you might find that information useful for your research.
Ivanka Kim says
December 29, 2018 at 9:53 amHi, Tamara!
Thank you so much for your research and all the work that you do! I just purchased a Kitchenaid 6 qt mixer and am about to return and exchange it for the 5 qt (mainly because the stainless steel attachments fit that size!). Can you please let us know as soon as you test those new attachments? I am really eager to find out before I order them.
Thank you!
– Ivanka
Tamara says
December 29, 2018 at 11:18 amI think they are here waiting to be tested. I try to wait to open boxes until I have the time to test them. I have a few boxes still to get through! :-), will see if I can get to them today!
T
Ivanka Kim says
January 2, 2019 at 5:48 pmThank you so much! That’d be wonderful if you already have them at hand. I exchanged my mixer today for the anniversary edition 5 qt. I suppose it is made in 2018. Makes you wonder why in this day and age such big and successful companies continue using harmful materials! Indeed, it came with those white coated beaters and the dull gray metal, awful looking whisk. I’m really nervous about using them. The mixer was an amazing Christmas gift to my family, but if the new stainless steel attachments contain lead…it will end up gathering dust in the closet. Health is more important than quick and fluffy egg whites.
Thank you again for providing all this useful information! I wouldn’t be aware of so many things if it weren’t for your work.
Tamara says
January 2, 2019 at 5:59 pmThank you.
Ivanka Kim says
January 17, 2019 at 10:10 pmHi Tamara!
Just wondering if you’ve had the chance to test those stainless steel attachments yet? Sorry to bother you about it again, I was just making sure I didn’t miss a post or a comment.
Thanks!
– Ivanka
Tamara says
January 18, 2019 at 8:13 pmHi Ivanka,
I thought someone had sent them in, but they didn’t (I have a queue of boxes lined up for testing at any given time) …. so I think I am still waiting for them to arrive in the mail. I will let you know when they do arrive!
Tamara
Ivanka Kim says
January 18, 2019 at 11:31 pmAll right! Thank you!
Ivanka Kim says
January 7, 2019 at 4:35 pmHi Tamara!
I thought you might like to know that KitchenAid responded to my question about their new anniversary edition mixer. I asked them specifically about their ceramic mixing bowl and the coated beaters/attachments. They said they’re all completely lead free. Hopefully they’re adopting more healthy production practices in their products? I really hope so!
I can forward you the whole email if you like.
God bless,
Ivanka
Tamara says
January 7, 2019 at 4:45 pmThank you, Ivanka – I would appreciate that!
My email is: TamaraRubin@mac.com
Tamara
Katrina P. says
February 17, 2019 at 9:52 pmHello Tamara,
Thank you for all you do. I recently came across your testing of Kitchenaid mixer attachments while doing research and comparison shopping on various stand mixer brands. I’d like to purchase a mixer soon, within a couple weeks. 1. Which stand mixer brands are you aware of that do not contain lead or other harmful materials? I’d prefer to not purchase a Kitchenaid as I’ve read the quality of this brand seems to have declined since it was purchased by Whirlpool (previously owned by Bogart). 2. Have you yet tested the stainless steel Kitchenaid attachments that you and Ivanka Kim have corresponded about last month? (5quart or 6 quart)? Would you please share the results asap? Thank you. Katrina.
Claire Crowe komarec says
April 4, 2019 at 9:05 amWe should all demand a full refund for them not making a food safe product. Companies need to start being held accountable for this negligance.
Ivanka Kim says
April 4, 2019 at 12:33 pmYes, Claire, I totally agree. When I emailed them, they assured me that the mixing attachments are all lead free…but you should see how bad they look! My mixer is only 3 months old and I’ve barely used it 2-3 times…and there’s already some white, weird looking little chunks falling off the whisk. Not water stains, some weird stuff. I doubt it’s safe to use it, so I ordered the stainless steel ones. (they don’t look amazing either, to be honest, but hopefully will be safer to use!)
Jennifer says
May 24, 2019 at 1:28 pmHi Ivanka,
I am considering ordering the stainless steel
attachments. I was wondering how they are working for you. I am hoping Tamara got the ones that were sent to her for testing.
Jennifer
Tamara says
May 24, 2019 at 11:41 pmHi Jennifer,
I never did get a set of those in the mail to test unfortunately. 🙁
Tamara
Ivanka Kim says
May 24, 2019 at 11:47 pmHi Jennifer,
I got the attachments right before I moved, so they’re literally still in the box. Hopefully I’ll get to try them tomorrow and I’ll let you know!
Cheers
– Ivanka
Carmelle says
April 4, 2019 at 2:16 pmEver one should demand a refund or make sure this information goes viral. The shaky coating on my 15 year old kitchen aid mixer she’d all of its website coating years ago, and I had NO idea, the metal under it was lead. That is so wrong. And I use mine four or five time a week.
Carren Panico says
July 16, 2019 at 4:23 amAre ones more recently manufactured lead free?
Tamara says
July 16, 2019 at 8:33 amHi Carren – no – based on the testing I have done to date I have not found this to be the case, unfortunately! – Tamara