Are yerba mate bombillas (straws) toxic?
Published: February 29, 2020
Photographic contributions by Avi Benjamin Rubin
Introduction (for those new to this website):
Tamara Rubin is an independent advocate for consumer goods safety. She is also a mother of Lead-poisoned children. She began testing consumer goods for toxicants in 2009 and was the parent-advocate responsible for finding Lead in the popular fidget spinner toys in 2017. Tamara uses high-precision XRF testing (a scientific method used by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission) to test consumer goods for metallic toxicants, including Lead, Cadmium, Mercury and Arsenic.
What is a bombilla?
Until recently, I had no idea what a bombilla was. I was introduced to them when I had the occasion to test a couple of Argentinian bombilla straws on a recent trip. It was only then that I learned about their intended use – as a traditional straw used to drink a specific very hot (and acidic) beverage: yerba mate. I was alarmed by the XRF test results – which showed very high levels of Lead and Antimony (as well as other concerning metals). Potential heavy metals poisoning with the regular (“normal / “as intended”) use of these – often ornately-decorated – metal straws seems like a very real risk.
Prior to testing these items, I was not familiar with this product, its use – nor its popularity. In researching this post over the past couple of days, I really “went down the rabbit hole” — of learning everything I could about bombilla (yerba mate straws), their origins, their history, their evolution, their usage and the materials typically used to make them (see above). Needless to say, as an advocate for Lead poisoning prevention and safety in consumer goods manufacturing, I was astounded by (and quite concerned about) the implications of what I learned. Below I will share with you the results of the XRF testing of the two straws pictured here, and then (below the full test results) I will discuss the potential health implications.
Mystery source of illnesses cluster caused by drinking yerba mate
In my inquiry, I read that medical researchers have been puzzled by the fact that drinking hot yerba mate is associated with a higher risk of cancer than is drinking cooler yerba mate (see Mayo Clinic quote below). The types of cancer linked to drinking hot (or very hot) yerba mate include cancers of the mouth, esophagus and lungs.
WebMD notes (see second quote below) that regular heavy ongoing consumption of Yerba Mate also appears to be causal of the following symptomatic expressions: “headache, anxiety, agitation, ringing in the ears, and irregular heartbeats” (symptoms also consistent with heavy metal poisoning.)
Sources agree that “more investigation needs to be done into the safety and side effects of yerba mate” – yet no one (from what I can see after several days of research online) is looking into these symptoms potentially being caused by heavy metal poisoning — due to using heavy metals-containing bombillas when drinking hot [or “very hot”] yerba mate.
per Mayo Clinic website:
per WebMD website:
Possible cause for alarm – and a recommendation:
Based on the bombilla (straw) testing I did (details reported below), if you regularly drink yerba mate in a traditional gourd with a metal bombilla, and have also been experiencing “headaches, anxiety, agitation, ringing in the ears, and/or irregular heartbeat”, you may want to ask your doctor or other health practitioner about getting yourself tested for possible heavy metal poisoning.
I believe it would be prudent to ask your doctor to test your hair, blood or urine for unsafe / unexpected levels of Lead, Antimony, Nickel and Copper. I am not a doctor — but, based on my considerable professional experience testing consumer goods, and working with hundreds (if not thousands) of Lead-poisoning victims over the course of the last 10+ years, I would recommend getting a full metals panel, if you are a regular user of one of these straws and that sort of testing is available to you.
XRF testing of two specific bombillas
(yerba mate straws)
Tests are done on each component of each straw for a minimum of 60 seconds each. All tests are done multiple times to confirm the results. Results are science-based, accurate and replicable. Testing is done using an XRF instrument (an X-Ray Fluorescence Spectrometer), which is the same instrument used by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission to screen consumer goods for the presence of potentially toxic heavy metals.
Continue reading below the image!
#1) Below are full XRF test results for the Bombilla (Yerba Mate Straw) pictured above with the small floral decorative element.
Continue reading below the image!
1.a.) Filter (above image):
- Lead (Pb): 6,105 +/- 588 ppm
- Tin (Sn): 40,700 +/- 700 ppm
- Zinc (Zn): 128,200 +/- 2,700 ppm
- Copper (Cu): 409,500 +/- 3,100 ppm
- Nickel (Ni): 411,200 +/- 3,000 ppm
- Iron (Fe): 856 +/- 325 ppm
- Titanium (Ti): 1,452 +/- 264 ppm
- Silver (Ag): 31 +/- 62 ppm
Note: given the small size and odd shape of the removable filter, consistent readings were unusually difficult to achieve — the readings fell between the range of 3,000 ppm and 12,000 ppm for Lead. To get a more “true” (precise) total Lead content reading, the component would need to be made flat (through melting or high-pressure compression). Based on my experience, I would anticipate that subsequent reading to be in the 20,000 to 40,000 ppm range after such flattening (when it would then easily be able to span the entire “testing window” of an XRF instrument).
Continue reading below the image!
1.b.) Threaded area where filter screws on (above image):
- Lead (Pb): 17,000 +/- 1,000 ppm
- Antimony (Sb): 391 +/- 133 ppm
- Tin (Sn): 21,500 +/- 600 ppm
- Zinc (Zn): 313,700 +/- 3,000 ppm
- Copper (Cu): 589,600 +/- 3,600 ppm
- Nickel (Ni): 53,200 +/- 1,200 ppm
- Iron (Fe): 2,650 +/- 394 ppm
- Titanium (Ti): 705 +/- 184 ppm
- Silver (Ag): 132 +/- 60 ppm
1.c.) Main functional tube of straw
- Tin (Sn): 37,600 +/ 600 ppm
- Bromine (Br): 4,118 +/- 190 ppm
- Zinc (Zn): 8,433 +/- 868 ppm
- Copper (Cu): 399,800 +/- 2,400 ppm
- Nickel (Ni): 543,900 +/- 2,500 ppm
- Iron (Fe): 454 +/- 231 ppm
- Titanium (Ti): 1,657 +/- 305 ppm
- Silver (Ag): 174 +/- 57 ppm
- Platinum (Pt): 968 +/- 638 ppm
- Cobalt (Co): 348 +/- 232 ppm
Continue reading below the image!
1.d.) Decorative Elements (flowers – above image)
- Lead (Pb): 65,200 +/- 2,000 ppm
- Tin (Sn): 57,100 +/- 1,100 ppm
- Zinc (Zn): 45,200 +/- 2,200 ppm
- Copper (Cu): 339,200 +/- 3,700 ppm
- Nickel (Ni): 461,500 +/- 3,900 ppm
- Titanium (Ti): 1,700 +/- 300 ppm
Continue reading below the image!
#2) Below are full XRF test results for the Bombilla (Yerba Mate Straw) pictured above (with the square fleur-de-lys decorative element).
- Lead (Pb): 10,200 +/- 900 ppm
- Tin (Sn): 32,700 +/- 800 ppm
- Bismuth (Bi): 387 +/- 242 ppm
- Zinc (Zn): 239,700 +/- 3,300 ppm
- Copper (Cu): 523,100 +/- 3,900 ppm
- Nickel (Ni): 189,500 +/- 2,400 ppm
- Iron (Fe): 1,313 +/- 389 ppm
- Titanium (Ti): 1,257 +/- 260 ppm
2.b.) Main functional tube of straw
- Tin (Sn): 38,200 +/ 600 ppm
- Bromine (Br): 8990 +/- 270 ppm
- Zinc (Zn): 73,900 +/- 1,700 ppm
- Copper (Cu): 433,900 +/- 2,400 ppm
- Nickel (Ni): 438,400 +/- 2,400 ppm
- Iron (Fe): 552 +/- 231 ppm
- Titanium (Ti): 2,478 +/- 383 ppm
- Nb: 1,776 +/- 181 ppm
Continue reading below the image!
2.c.) Decorative Elements (fleur-de-lys badge)
- Lead (Pb): 461,900 +/- 3,500 ppm
- Antimony (Sb): 80,700 +/- 1,500 ppm
- Tin (Sn): 52,700 +/- 1,200 ppm
- Selenium (Se): 1,847 +/- 445 ppm
- Gold (Au): 3,548 +/- 725 ppm
- Copper (Cu): 128,700 +/- 2,600 ppm
- Nickel (Ni): 259,100 +/- 3,500 ppm
- Iron (Fe): 1,338 +/- 803 ppm
- Titanium (Ti): 2,222 +/- 414 ppm
- Zirconium (Zr): 1,865 +/- 237 ppm
- Cobalt (Co): 1,191 +/- 627 ppm
Where were the toxicants found?
- In Most Components: Toxic heavy metals were found both in the external decorative elements of the straws, and in the food-contact surfaces.
- In Decorative Elements: The decorative elements applied to the exterior (non-food-contact) surfaces of the straw tested positive for the highest levels of toxic heavy metals.
- In The Removable Filters: Of perhaps the greatest concern (even to a level of “alarm”): the part that you directly submerge in the hot beverage (the removable metal “filter” component that is supposed to filter out the impurities of the yerba mate as you drink it) is made of a high-Lead-content metal (possibly qualifying as Leaded brass – and per the above comment in the testing section – possibly as high as the 20,000 to 40,000 ppm range.) The filters have significantly lower Lead levels than the decorative elements, but they are high enough to potentially cause harm given the functionality of the component.
- In The Filter Threads: finally, the threaded section that the filter attaches to also appears to be made of Leaded brass.
The only analogy I can think of is if someone found the purest spring water (famous for its purported health benefits) and then proceeded to drink it through a Lead-pipe! While scientific study needs to be done, based on my years of experience, I am fairly certain that drinking very hot yerba mate though these Leaded “filters” is very likely causing at least some level of Lead contamination of the beverage. This is exacerbated by the fact that the high-lead filter part would actually normally sit submerged in the hot beverage continuously while you drink.
How much Lead is too much Lead?
I expect items like this are not at all regulated for toxicity in Argentina. The only relevant standard that can be applied (the only standard limiting total Lead content – as detectable with an XRF instrument- in consumer goods in the United States) is the standard for items manufactured as items intended for use by children. For these items only (items made and sold for kids today) Lead must be below 90 ppm in the paint, glaze or coating and below 100 ppm in the substrate of an item. Of course these straws are not made for children, but that does not make them any less toxic – especially with Lead levels in some components approaching 500,000 ppm! [That’s 50% Lead!]
Could using one of these bombillas really be poisoning me?
Based on my preliminary findings (details shown above) of high levels of multiple toxic heavy metals in two separate yerba mate bombilla straws [purchased in Argentina, pictured here on this post], heavy metal poisoning would certainly appear to be a possible explanation (a primary factor or a contributing factor) for both the “mysterious” chronic symptoms noted above (possibly incorrectly attributed to the beverage, not the hardware), as well as the associated cancers. Frankly, I am actually shocked — given the tradition behind (and the current popularity of) this drink, along with the purported health benefits of the beverage — that no scientific body appears to have made an effort to look into potential population-level heavy metal poisoning as a possible consequence of the use of these popular implements.
If you are a fluent Spanish speaker and could do some googling for potential studies written in Spanish, I would appreciate knowing more about what you find as well. I was only able to do a productive search in English. My searches in Spanish were limited by my fairly limited knowledge of the Spanish written language – but I did try!
Touching these straws is bad too!
In addition to my concern for potential poisoning from ingestion of yerba mate that has been contaminated by passing through one of these toxic straws (and the attached Leaded-brass filters), I have concerns for potential poisoning of the user caused by merely handling (touching and possibly fidgeting with) these straws.
Regular fidgeting with an item like this (especially one like the one shown here with the fleur-de-lys which is nearly 50% Lead on the decorative element) could possibly cause unsafe levels of Lead and Antimony to wear off on to the hands of the owner, toxicants which might then later be ingested (as could happen when eating an apple, french fries, burrito or corn chips with your hands after fidgeting with the straw.)
Can you buy straws like these today?
Yes, apparently it seems they are available everywhere! The straws pictured here are just two examples of metal Bombilla straws (purchased in Argentina by one of my readers.) I understand from some of the research I have done (see the images below) that this common removable filter component [which is quite high in Lead] is an indicator that these are a newer style (not, for example, some vintage version of the product). There seem to be hundreds – if not thousands – of iterations of these straws available online, and I will work to test more examples to try to determine just how pervasive this particular – very disturbing – design / supply chain specification is…from the seemingly endless product listings (featuring photos of similar-looking screw-on filters) that I have seen so far, I am not encouraged!
Continue reading below the images.
From the YerbaMatero.com website:
Below are several examples of Bombilla straws with screw on filters (similar to the ones tested above.)
But Tamara, I thought yerba mate is good for you!
Ironically, yerba mate is widely considered to confer an array of purported health benefits — relieving fatigue; supporting weight loss; easing depression; treating headaches and other conditions — however, research has shown that habitual (regular and heavy) use of yerba mate might cause some of the very conditions it is alleged to relieve.
My hypothesis (as stated above) is that it may not be the beverage itself that causes the maladies that have been shown to bear a statistical association with its habitual use, but perhaps rather the use of toxic heavy metal-laden bombillas with normal / regular (& heavy) consumption of yerba mate that may turn out to be the real culprit.
Even more shocking, these are known to contain Lead!
As you can see from the screenshot above [from YerbaMatero.com], it is known that these metal straws might contain Lead [and Copper and Nickel – Nickel as a primary component of stainless steel], yet the only warning I found is the one above — that suggests folks “avoid ones made of iron or tin or coated with copper or nickel plating”(!); I could not find any online warning for potential harmful impacts of Lead or Antimony in metal bombillas!
Conclusion based on the XRF test results:
Toxic heavy metals found (at unsafe levels) in the two bombillas picture here include both:
- Antimony: known to cause cancer in rats and respiratory issues in humans, &
- Lead: known for millennia to cause neurological disorders, and also – more recently – known to cause headaches; an increased risk of heart disease; a compromised immune system (that could make an exposed person more prone to certain cancers) – among a very long list of various other known health impacts.
Considering the specific use of the objects (daily use in the consumption of a very hot beverage, that is also fairly acidic), these straws also contain what may perhaps be potentially-concerning levels of two additional metals – specifically Nickel and Copper – which also have the potential to be harmful to humans in high doses.
What should we do about this?
- If at all possible, cease using any metal bombillas (as they may all be contaminated with one metal or another that is unsafe to use with the hot acidic beverage as intended).
- Revert to the traditional natural (& undecorated / unpainted / unstained) cane bombillas if you must drink your beverage using the traditional gourd and straw. [Sorry I don’t have a link for this, I have not found one online that I am confident is likely paint-free and stain-free.]
- If you are or have been regular / daily – or heavy – user of yerba mate using a metal bombilla, ask your doctor for a heavy metal test immediately.
- Consider drinking your yerba mate cool (or at least cool-er) — and without a bombilla.
- Bottled yerba mate from the store should not be a concern, unless you heat it and drink it in a traditional vessel with a bombilla.
- I am hopeful that with my readership base (I had more than 1,948,000 readers in over 200 countries in 2019 alone – including 192 readers in Argentina!) this information will get to the proper authorities in Argentina so a public health warning can be issued. [My readers help me in this work by sharing the information in my posts with their communities, local governments and manufacturers.]
As always, thank you for reading and for sharing my posts. Just sharing this post (in particular) may actually help protect someone you know personally from potential heavy metal poisoning.
For updates on this matter (as they come up!) please subscribe to my email list (it’s free!)
Please let me know if you have any questions. I will do my best to answer any questions as they come in – but with recent traffic on the blog I have not been able to answer all questions in real time.
For additional images continue reading.
Not only are the straws potentially concerning – but the gourds (like the one pictured below) might also be high in heavy metals. The color of the brass in the one pictured directly below makes me concerned that this might be Leaded brass.