Published: Wednesday, June 15, 2022
(But I’ve been meaning to write this one for a while now!)
First please take a look at the photos below. This is what happened to my son (who was 16 years old at the time these photos were taken) after he had ONE SIP of his friend’s light pink bubble tea. These photos were taken in the hospital. We have many more photos (of every part of his body from that day) but these are the ones he was comfortable with me sharing here on my website. Every single part of his body was impacted. Every.Part. This was a terrifying incident — in which we were worried that the acute systemic allergic reaction could possibly impact his airways / ability to breathe. This also is just one of many, many incidents in which he had a reaction to food dye, but this was the first time it happened when he had an “adult-sized” body. We had – mistakenly – thought, up to this point, that perhaps he had “grown-out” of this allergy…but we were wrong — and this time (and subsequent times too) the reaction was verging on life-threatening. As a result of this incident, he was given a prescription for two Epi-pens. Continue reading below the images.
The three photos below are the right side of his torso
Photo 1 of 3Photo 2 of 3Photo 3 of 3
The photo below is the front of his torso – showing his left side -when things had begun to subside.
The photo below is the top of his right thigh – this area and around his groin were particularly affected.
The photo below is the lower right side of his torso & top of his right hip
The photo below is a close up of the front of his torso
Here’s the story…
As a “natural-minded” / “crunchy” / “organic” mama, I never (intentionally) let any of my kiddos have any food dye, but as a human living in modern society, it slipped through the cracks every now and then – in spite of my vigilance.
20+ years ago, when my eldest son was little, we held a post-Halloween ritual — in which we would go through all of the candy, and if it had nasty stuff, like “hydrogenated hoodoo” [our sons’ name for Hydrogenated oils], or corn syrup, or artificial food dyes, we would unwrap it and flush it down the toilet! Usually that would leave us with just chocolate, and a few other odds and ends [as this was before I knew that chocolate was one of the food items with the highest Lead levels! (More on that here)].
After my children were acutely Lead-poisoned (in August of 2005) and were violently ill as a result of their exposure, I became even more strict about food dyes (and made sure they didn’t eat things like birthday cakes / cupcakes at people’s houses / school if there were any question of dyes in the frosting, and that sort of thing). I knew food dyes were “bad” — but I didn’t know exactly how bad they could be!… Early on (shortly after the boys were poisoned), one of the kiddos had an incident with M & M’s, and then the other one had an incident with popsicles [we quickly figured out that one was obviously reacting to red food dye, while the other was hyper-sensitive to yellow food dye!] Each incident resulted in pretty big hives — especially considering both kids’ relatively tiny size at that time!
When this seemed to happen
One thing I began to notice with these exposures (and reactions) is that they were more likely to happen if the children were already “compromised” or sick (like if they had a cold coming on, or a fever – and then accidentally ingested some food dye – they were more likely to have a big reaction). This became an especially challenging thing to deal with upon that realization — as almost EVERY childhood medication is “color-coded”/marketing-branded through the use of food dyes(!) – so we had to start making sure to have dye-free medications (Advil, Benadryl, etc.) on-hand for emergencies (and when traveling), because we couldn’t risk the kiddos having a reaction to the medication that we were using to treat them for an illness!
The first big incident was with A.J. and Facepaint – the Halloween after he was poisoned.
Halloween 2005 was the first major incident… It was about 2-1/2 months after the boys were Lead-poisoned, and I think we painted A.J.‘s face with clown makeup for one of his pre-school Halloween parties [it wasn’t for the main trick-or-treat night because he was Harpo Marx that year, if I recall correctly!] There were red cheeks, and a red mouth (and probably a red star or heart here and there for accents — I pride myself on my face-painting skills and have done more than my share of volunteer face-painting at festivals, fairs, and birthday parties over the years!)
After school [he went in the mornings – like 9 to 1-ish, if I recall correctly] we brought him home and washed the face-paint off [gently, using a skin-friendly lotion, as I normally do]. After all the paint had been thoroughly removed, there were red marks all over his face. At first we thought they were just marks / stains somehow left-behind from the paint — but then I realized they were actually swollen welts everywhere the red paint had been (and extending beyond the areas with the red paint by a bit in each spot)! That was the first time I realized we really had a problem.
Avi and the popsicles… a couple of years later…
After he was Lead-poisoned, until he was about 5 or 6 years old, Avi used to get febrile seizures “on the regular” (his body couldn’t regulate temperature in response to illness and it was actually quite terrifying!). Whenever he got even a tiny bit sick, his fever would spike to 104 or 105 degrees, and we would have to rush him to the hospital!
When he was about three years old, he was having a seizure and we (by this point) were “seasoned veterans”, and knew all the tips and tricks that we should try at home before bringing him to the hospital. One of these tricks was to feed him ‘papa-cicles” (our kids’ word for popsicles — not to be confused with “mama-cicles”, our kids word for motorcycles at the time!). We had a specific brand of popsicle that we would get at the local natural foods store in emergencies when he was sick. This brand was pretty “clean” — it had no corn syrup, and no artificial dyes – it was primarily frozen fruit juice [although it did have some cane sugar]. My color-blind husband KNEW what the brand was; he KNEW what the box looked like (by the shape and size of the packaging, and by the photo on the box – because we had bought it many times before), so when he went to the store (just before closing at 10 or 11 at night) he grabbed the box, bought it, rushed home, put the box in the freezer, grabbed a yellow popsicle out of the box and brought it into the bedroom where I was cradling and soothing Avi with a cool washcloth on his head. Avi ate the popsicle…within a few minutes there were ginormous hives ALL over his body [a potentially life-threatening acute systemic allergic reaction]!
We couldn’t figure out what was going on (we gave him some dye-free Benadryl to try to bring down the swelling) and then I asked my husband to show me the popsicle box. It wasn’t the right popsicles! Apparently, since the last time we had bought them, the company came out with a new type of popsicle (same box, same branding, similar image – slightly-different color scheme on the box) and that new type had different flavors – some of which had food dyes! So unbeknownst to us, we had given Avi a yellow popsicle which had yellow food dye — and he swelled up like a balloon! Lesson learned: always carefully check the ingredients on the box EVEN IF YOU THINK YOU KNOW THE PRODUCT! So many food and personal-care products change their “natural” formulations after being bought out by larger companies (and I believe that is what happened in this case).
My older son didn’t think this was still a problem – this was just a story from when he was a kid, and he had outgrown it…
“Unfortunately” (fortunately?), as my kiddos aged we were so strict about food dye that we never had this problem after we hit the tweens and teen years… Accordingly, they actually didn’t remember these experiences (from when they were very young) — only what they had heard us tell them about it…so it would make sense that they didn’t consider it a “real” threat. [I think the kids thought of it more as “family lore” by then, vs. something they needed to be responsible for for the rest of their lives!] So on the day these photos were taken, my son was “a bit under the weather”, and had a sip of his friend’s pink bubble tea – he didn’t even consider that the pink bubble tea had red dye and might be an issue [he had gotten bubble tea before — when he wasn’t sick — and hadn’t had any reaction, and he wasn’t thinking about the food dye considerations]. He called me from his friend’s house, and then immediately came home…and that’s when we rushed him to the hospital.
During that hospital visit we received a prescription for an Epi-pen, and he was given two to have for emergencies.
We have not been able to get this prescription renewed, because of our broken healthcare system (the prescription originated at a hospital Emergency Room, and so – years later – no-one there will renew it…and he’s too old to see his – West Coast – pediatric doctor now, and the practice says that they can’t renew the potentially life-saving emergency prescription – as “he is not a current patient”… and his – East Coast – college medical system says they can’t prescribe that “without a direct history of incident/treatment”, and yadda-yadda…). [And so while the Epi-pens we have are now are expired, we heard that they still work when expired, so for the time-being, he keeps them with him just in case!]
Mosquitoes and Bees, too…
In our August 2020 cross country drive we had a similar incident where my son’s face “blew-up” (the other kids said he looked like “The Elephant Man”!) after being bitten by mosquitos. Bee stings with these boys can be equally problematic. The point in mentioning that this concern goes BEYOND food dye is because this cluster of reactions illustrates how the immune system of kiddos who have been Lead-poisoned is often compromised in many ways. This is a compromised immune system that cannot ward off “normal” things that most other children deal with without issue — and while the link to food dye reactions in children who have a history of Lead exposure has not yet been formally scientifically studied, it should be. [In stark contrast, my oldest kiddo (who was not Lead-poisoned as a baby) did not have any issues like this at all — with either mosquito bites, bee stings, or any food dyes].
A request for scientists and researchers
This is a not an isolated incident (not isolated to my children). In my 15+ years as a childhood Lead poisoning prevention activist working with countless families of Lead poisoned children around the world – I have seen similar allergies over and over again in children – allergies producing reactions that appear to be much more significant (and more frequent) in children who have tested positive for Lead in their blood in their lifetime.
If you are a medical researcher and you are reading this, please consider taking this study on (I can easily get you a decent-sized cohort of children with a history of Lead exposure to study!). A study of this issue [and some “hard evidence” to back the concern for potential harmful impacts of food dye on children who have been exposed to Lead at some point in their life] could help a lot of kids — and could:
- help make it possible for these kids to get the medical interventions they need and deserve, like Epi pens! [Even with these photos as evidence of his reaction, we have not yet been able to get our son’s prescription renewed! :-(] and
- possibly help support the larger movement to get coal tar dyes (like Red #40!) outlawed in the United States (especially for use in food and medications.)
A plea to parents. This could happen to your kid (or a kid you know) too; that’s also why I am sharing this
I often hear of people who dismiss other parents’ concerns for allergies that their children have…concerns for peanut allergies, gluten allergies, food dye allergies and more.
Please know that these concerns can be very, very real — life-threateningly real! When someone says their child has “a life-threatening allergy to food dye” (or peanuts, or gluten or anything for that matter!) PLEASE take the concern seriously, and treat the situation accordingly. Just because a specific concern (like the link between childhood Lead exposure and food dye reactions) may not have (yet) been well-studied, does not mean it is not a very real problem threatening the lives and well-being of countless children.
Thank you for taking the time to read my sons’ story.
Owner – Lead Safe Mama, LLC
Mother of Lead Poisoned Children
For those new to this website:
Tamara Rubin is a Federal-award-winning independent advocate for consumer goods safety and a documentary filmmaker. She is also a mother of Lead-poisoned children. Tamara’s sons were acutely Lead-poisoned in August of 2005. She began testing consumer goods for toxicants in 2009 and was the parent-advocate responsible for finding Lead in the popular fidget spinner toys in 2017. Tamara uses XRF testing (a scientific method used by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission) to test consumer goods for toxicants (specifically heavy metals), including Lead, Cadmium, Mercury, Antimony, and Arsenic. All test results reported on this website are science-based, accurate, and replicable. Items are tested multiple times, to confirm the test results for each component tested and reported on. Please click through to this link to learn more about the testing methodology used for the test results discussed and reported on this website
Tim Pye says
Very bad, very sad; and there seems to be some science to support this.
Lead exposure and increased food allergic sensitization in U.S. children and adults
Mener et al, 2014
Exposure to lead was associated with increased odds of sensitization to food allergens in adult but not children participants.
I guess 16 years all is getting towards being an adult.
But my son’s allergies started right after his Lead exposure Tim, when he was three. So no – not relevant. I think this study has some bias or not a large enough cohort of Lead poisoned children. Also I think if they specifically addressed food-dye allergy they would find a much stronger correlation – and it is also not relevant because they were not looking at acutely lead poisoned children (just general population level lead exposure.)
Tim Pye says
I am looking for evidence to support an association between lead and allergies because your son’s condition may not be related to lead exposure. The NTP Monograph on Lead concludes that there is limited evidence of “Increased hypersensitivity/allergy by skin prick test to allergens” in children with blood lead concentrations below 10 µg/dL. “Limited” in this context is quite strong evidence, but no beyond doubt.
As is often the case, Tim – you misunderstand the context for what I have written. The specific point clearly stated is that research needs to be done and has not been done. Working with THOUSANDS of families over nearly two decades on this issue I am certain there is a causal link AND we need to request that the scientists we know spend some time investigating this further. (I understand my family is just one anecdotal case, but as you may notice from comments here and on social media – it is one among many.) I have no question about the causal link for my family – given the specifics of our 6 person cohort.
I do thank you for sharing these links however – links which support my assertion that more research needs to be done.
Honey Bee says
That’s awful. Looks really painful and itchy. I was diagnosed with food allergies 13 years ago and I’m an adult. Over 20 food allergies. I can sympathize with what your children are going through. I don’t think a person ever gets used to food allergies. I hope they have a lot more days feeling good and healthy
Nancy Christie says
My significant other had a heart attack in 2009, when he was 61 years old (with no prior symptoms or any other serious health issues). After treatment with a stent and medications, he recovered but was found to have a severe peanut allergy he never had before, and was hospitalized the first time it happened. He believes the medications triggered the allergy. Now it is controlled by careful diet and mild antihistamines, and a strong antihistamine plus Epi-Pen in case of a reaction. I wonder if the mechanism of the medication (or food dye in the meds) is similar to what you have described for lead poisoning leading to allergic reactions. (He has not had a reaction in several years, ever since I discovered he was buying walnuts from bulk food containers that are easily peanut-contaminated. Now he only eats walnuts that we buy in the shell and crack them ourselves.)